Insights

Inside the Redline


Fountain pen writing on lined paper

By Charisse Dino, Commercial Contracts Lawyer at modCounsel

I’ve been working many years in this, and by now, the moment a contract lands in your inbox, you already start reading it differently depending on where it came from. A US MSA reads differently from a UK vendor agreement. An NDA from India is a different exercise altogether. Each carries its own assumptions, its own rhythm, before you’ve even opened the first clause. Building that instinct takes years, and no tool can fully replace it.

At ModCounsel, I handle commercial contracts, mostly SaaS-related, maybe 85% of what comes through. The rest is consultancy, provision of services, and partnerships. Clients range from mid-sized companies to large enterprises. Most arrive overwhelmed by volume and short on time, convinced that speed is the answer.

It’s only half the answer.

Quality and Speed Have to Coexist

When clients come to us, the easy explanation is volume. They’re getting bombarded with MSAs, renewals, and amendments and they need capacity. But what they actually need is quality and fast turnaround at the same time, and those two things are genuinely hard to find together.

I’ve had contracts land at 100 pages, urgent, due back in 24 hours. For that to work well, you can’t just move fast. You have to already know what good looks like for that client, in that industry, under those governing laws. That knowledge doesn’t arrive with the contract. You build it over time.

Every Client Is Its Own World

When a new contract comes in, say a healthcare MSA with no existing playbook, the first thing I do is make sure I understand the industry. Healthcare has specific requirements. So does anything touching AI. A generic review lens won’t hold up.

Once I know the context, I move through the contract methodically. I start with the preamble, work through the substantive clauses, and land at governing law and miscellaneous provisions. The structure is predictable. What’s inside isn’t. Liability shows up differently in a UK contract than in a US one. The language is more indirect, more layered, but the risk is the same. You just have to know how to read it. For clients without a playbook, I review against what’s typical, fair, and acceptable in their industry. Where there’s room, I push for what’s client-beneficial.

Where AI Enables and Where Judgment Applies

A contract rarely resolves in one pass. There are almost always at least two rounds of back and forth before we reach a clean, execution-ready version. This is where speed and quality have to work together, and ModInsight, our internal AI, is a big part of how that happens.

For first-round reviews, ModInsight saves me 30 to 35 minutes, more on longer documents. It cuts my review time and helps flag issues early. I’ll also give it a clause I’ve drafted and ask it to rewrite in bullet points or tighten the language. It’s like my little secretary. When the counterparty comes back with specific concerns to address one by one across 80 or 90 pages, I handle each one myself. You have to read each comment carefully, understand what’s behind it, and respond to it specifically. AI can’t do that at that level yet. That’s where experience earns its place.

The Patterns You Build Over Time

About six months in with a client, you start to see the patterns. The counterparty always pushes back on a particular governing law clause. The client always needs a BAA before anything else moves forward. The payment terms always need to reflect a longer internal approval cycle than what the counterparty is offering.

When you see those patterns, the right move is to build them in. Make the recurring concession a fallback so you’re not escalating over the same thing every quarter. Start from mutuality where the risk is low. It reduces friction, shortens negotiation, and gets the deal done faster.

These aren’t dramatic changes. But they accumulate, and over time they change how smoothly a client’s contracts move.

Write It Down

If there’s one thing I see teams tolerate too long, it’s carrying their client knowledge entirely in their heads. Whether it’s a formal playbook, running notes, or logged client preferences, write it down. Memory fails. I don’t trust myself to remember which client has a specific requirement versus another. The notes save you. Humans make mistakes, the same as AI. We cannot always put everything to memory. However advanced we become, your own notes will always save the day.

What Makes It Worth It

When a client says she’s relieved to find out I’m handling her contracts because I already know what they want and what they need, that makes my heart full. It means the work goes beyond reviewing clauses. It’s getting to know your client like a friend. That’s what I show up to do, and it’s still the part of the job I care about most.

Want this thinking applied to your contracts?

Start with a free contract health check from a senior practitioner.